Monday, February 2, 2009

I drank toilet water but never let go of my patriotism

By James Munyaneza
The New Times-Kigali
October 1, 2007

David Munyurangabo, 64, was born in Nyanza, Southern Province, before he was driven from the country in early the 60s as a teenager. For many years, Munyurangabo – who is today a commissioner in charge of the Eastern Province in the Rwanda Demobilisation and Reintegration Commission (RDRC) – participated in liberation quests, which saw him thrown into prisons in Tanzania and Burundi. The balding ex-soldier-turned-liberation hero speaks on his hair-raising past and offers advice on patriotism in this interview with James Munyaneza.

Qn: On July 4 you were awarded a medal for your contribution to the liberation cause. As we commemorate the Patriotism Day, do you think Rwandans are patriotic?

A: Normally, I am not a pessimistic person but what I see today is worrying. What is happening is a sharp contrast to how people used to behave in the past. For instance, Rwandan refugees used to be more united and had much love for their motherland even when they had been denied the right to live in it.

Qn: Could one say that that feeling for lack of belonging and a home was the main factor that used to motivate Rwandan refugees in the past years?

A: Obviously, that itself contributed much to their commitment. We were a rejected people, and even when you would do anything to be reintegrated in the local communities of the host countries, you would still be discriminated against. Such discrimination was even institutionalised. I remember in Burundi, a Rwandan primary school pupil was required to obtain 75 percent to be promoted, while Burundians needed only 55 percent. That was something official.

Qn: And was that applied to Rwandans only, not other foreigners? A: Even children of other foreigners were subjected to that policy. However, the other foreigners were the French, Belgians and Congolese. All those had their own schools. There were ecole (school) Francaise, ecole Belges and ecole Zairoise (Congolese), and that is where their children studied from. However, that experience taught us how to stand up and work hard for ourselves even in refugee life.

Qn: How did you do it?

A: We started to mobilise Rwandan refugees to put together their efforts and set up schools in refugee camps. We encouraged them to take their children to schools and to embrace the culture of working hard. We always told them that their future rested in their hands, and told them how imperative it was to prepare their offspring for the years ahead.

Qn: Tell me something about your contribution to liberation struggles.

A: (laughs). It is a long, long, long story. I started liberation activities after school in 1962 when I was 18 years old. I and many others sacrificed their personal pursuits, and started to look at broader problems affecting Rwandans. There were countless problems affecting Rwandans at the time. Some had been chased out of their country; others were living in Rwanda like they were not citizens, and generally the country was suffering brutality and social injustices caused by the dictatorial regimes of the time. The leadership of the time had put individual interests ahead of national interests, and the whole country was slipping into a reign of terror. It is because of all that that a number of Rwandans, myself inclusive, from various places and countries began the process of liberation, and that dream came true 13 years ago.

Qn: And how did you personally participate in that cause?

A: My participation falls in the category of Rwandans who had been expelled from their country. I was part of Ingangurarugo, a rebel group formed shortly after the 1959 Tutsi expulsion from Rwanda, which then Rwandan authorities nicknamed Inyenzi (Cockroaches).

We launched a guerrilla-style rebellion through Umutara (now in the eastern Province) in the 1962, but were later repulsed and we retreated to Tanzania. However, on reaching there (Tanzania), the Rwandan government asked Tanzanians to arrest and deport us to Rwanda. Following an understanding between both sides, Tanzania deported (our colleagues) Numa, Mpambara and Nyabujangwe.

We were later told that the three were executed from Ruhengeri.

Qn: How did you survive?

A: It was miracle. I and one Karakire were arrested and detained in Muyenzi in Ngara (in western Tanzania). As we were there waiting for fate, a soccer team of inmates from another prison in Muhweza (also in Ngara region) visited us for a friendly match.

I was included on our prisoners’ team. I had never played football before and was trembling, and nervous to come in contact with the ball and opponent players. I was just running all over the pitch.

However, something unbelievable happened in the game. As I was running near the opponents’ goalmouth, someone hit the ball, which deflected off me and ended up in the goal. That created scenes of madness and I was lifted up by many people including prison policemen.

I had accidentally become a hero because it was the winning goal. After the match, I was hosted by prison officials and did not sleep inside the prison that night. I was also immediately appointed team captain.

However, I told them that I had no clothes with me, and since I had everyone’s ear I was granted permission to go home and get clothes. I left, went through Muyenzi and finally crossed to Kigamba camp in Burundi. That is how I survived. After sometime, Karakire was also freed and later joined me in Burundi.

Qn: Wow…. then what happened in Burundi?

A: We were also harassed there. We were arrested on a number of occasions. For instance on April 21, 1965, thirty-one of us were arrested. A decision was reached to deport us to Rwanda but we were saved by the (then Burundian) King Mwambutsa, whom we had in one way or the other also assisted. We were detained for five months in Mpinga Central Prison in Bujumbura.

Later, another man called Butera, a son to Francois Rukeba, was also arrested and brought to the same prison. (Rukeba was the president of the Union Nationale Rwandaise (UNR), one of the oldest Rwandan political parties). Life in that prison was very harsh. Each of us was detained in a small latrine room.

From April through August we were drinking running water of the toilet. The toilets had no window apart from a small opening the size of a plate, through which sometimes they passed a plate of food to keep us alive. It was a terrible situation.

One day, I don’t know how we found ourselves out. We fled to Zaire (now the Democratic Republic of Congo) where we joined a rebellion led by Pierre Murera. That rebellion had the likes of Laurent Desire Kabila (who later became Congo’s president) and Che Guevara. (Che was a Cuban revolutary, who left his ministerial position and went to support liberation struggles in other parts of the world. He was Industry minister).

We joined that rebellion (against the then Congolese government of Mobutu Sese Seko) because we had fled from Burundi and that was the only choice we had. However, we later pulled out and returned to Burundi. Members of our group continued to be persecuted, and many of them were killed including our leader Jean Kayitare, who was Rukeba’s son. He (Kayitare) was killed by a Burundian army Captain called Nyanka.

Qn: You seem to be acquainted with the operations of Ingangurarugo or Inyenzi as you were commonly referred to. Were you part of the High Command?

A: It’s true, I was working closely with Kayitare. I was part of the High Command. There were a number of others, some of them are still alive. Those still live include Joseph Bitangimpuruza alias Mwarimu, Dolphine Gasana, Alphonse Muhindanziga, Desire Ruzindana, Charles Ngoga, Viatore Habyarimana and Romeka. Another comrade Alloys Ngurumbe passed away just three weeks ago. There were a number of others that passed away. We used to call each other Kamarade (comrade).

Qn: When you returned to Burundi, did you settle peacefully? A: Not really. The same problems persisted. The government of Rwanda continued to ask Burundian authorities to hand us over to them. Because of that pressure as well as other political deals between both countries, Burundi decided to expel me, Rukeba, Cleophas Nyagahene, Ngurumbe, Ildephonse, and others.

In December 1979, we were given a two-week ultimatum to leave the country. I applied for asylum in Kenya but was denied saying that they had already accepted Rukeba. Nyagahene secured an asylum in Zaire (now DRC), while Ildephonse went to Belgium. I had nowhere to go. It was an extremely difficult situation, and the ultimatum had already run out. I would go to the offices of UNHCR in the night and return to camps during daytime.

They (UNHCR) applied and obtained an asylum for me in Canada, but told me that I will have to go alone and my family would join me after six months. I didn’t like the idea of going alone, and I found Canada to be very far from home.

By going there, I would have lost touch with home, and other Rwandans with whom we were sharing refugee problems. I rejected the offer. But I had a Burundian friend called Rutagamirwa. He was known to then Burundian president (Col. Jean Baptist) Bagaza because the latter was his son-in-law. He (Rutagamirwa) arranged a meeting between me and Bagaza, to introduce my problem. We later met at Rutagamirwa’s home.

After a brief conversation, Rutagamirwa requested Bagaza if he cannot bail me out. The president asked his head of external and internal security agencies Colonel Nzohabanayo, who was present, to look into my issue. I had a deep sigh of relief upon hearing that. He (Nzohabanayo) gave me an appointment next day. However, when we met he advised me to go to another country and spend there three months, after which I should come back to Burundi. Things went back to square one. I went to Kinshasa in Zaire.

Upon reaching there, I found a demonstration staged by Rwandan refugees in Kinshasa to denounce Burundi’s decision to expel us. They were demonstrating at Burundi’s embassy in Kinshasa. After three months, I returned to Burundi and went straight to the office of Colonel Nzohabanayo as he had instructed me.

However, things turned worse. He was mad at me. He accused me of inciting a demonstration in Kinshasa at their embassy. But after many days, I convinced him that I was innocent. After months, I managed to convince him that I was innocent and he let me stay in the country. They however continued to hide me whenever Rwandan delegations visited to avoid a political clash with Kigali. All that happened between 1979 and 1984.

After sometime, I settled down in Ngara in Bujumbura until 1990 when I joined RPA (Rwandese Patriotic Army) on October 8. But before then, I had met RPA commander (Maj. Gen.) Fred Rwigema after he and other Rwandans participated in Uganda’s liberation struggle which ended in 1986.

 He (Rwigema) would come to Burundi, and I myself would travel to Uganda. We had also met a number of Rwandan refugees especially in Nairobi.

Qn: Going by your words, your experience as a refugee was full of nightmares. What was the secret behind that undying spirit despite all the hurdles? A: Nothing but the need for a belonging, and for freedom of all Rwandans. I love to be free. Today, Rwandans have returned home; they have a nation they call home; to work for their nation.

Qn: After all that, do you think Rwandans at the present need to embrace that spirit? A: What we need is to keep that spirit; the culture of patriotism should be rooted deep in our families; our children should be taught to love their country, so that they grow ready to make sacrifices for their nation. Many people sacrificed their lives for this country, for us all.

We should therefore carry on the fight by say, working hard, being ready to defend our country, and living in peace and harmony as one people. The judiciary should do its job well; injustices should be done away with so that we don’t fall back into the same situation that led to the liberation struggle.


Related articles:
The Acronym IN.YE.NZI: A Symbol of Bravery

Rwandan private print media on the eve of the genocide

Interview with Aloys Ngurumbe on the origin of the terminology "inyenzi"

A TRIBUTE TO GISA [GENERAL FRED RWIGEMA], A YOUNG MAN WITH AN INDESCRIBABLE BEAUTY

U Rwanda rwa cyera kugeza INYENZI zitera
(The Rwanda Histrory Until the INYENZI Civil War )

5 Comments:

At February 5, 2009 at 11:17 PM , Blogger Mamadou Kouyate said...

Dear Jackie,

Thanks for readind and for leaving a comment.

Although your praise to IN.YE.NZI may somehow be justified owing to your life as a former Rwandan refugee, I am left to wonder where your wisdom may be.

During those difficult moments you spent abroad as a Rwandan refugee did you learn anything that might make you feel more human?

If all of those moments only fuelled your current anger against your fellow citizens it is time to let real progressive activists bring about the healing you so desperately need so that your anger can no longer be passed on to your generation and generations.

Do you know that criminals are neither brave nor heroes? What bravery do you see in killing innocent civilians, women, children, and elderly people?

Indeed, if fueling hatred among Rwandans and incitating the Rwandan people to commit acts of genocide was the intention lying behind the acronym IN.YE.NZI, the leaders of the IN.YE.NZI rebel movement, including your hero David Munyurangabo, should be held accountable for all of the cycles of violence that characterized the First Republic of Rwanda not to mention the Rwandan civil war launched by the RPF-INKOTANYI (a metamorhosis of the former IN.YE.NZI rebel movement that ravaged Rwanda in the 1960s) from the Ugandan territory in 1990, a civil war that ultimately ended with the Rwandan genocide in 1994.

Concerning the responsibility of the RPF in the Rwandan tragedy, as a Rwandan fellow sympathizer of the INYENZI and de facto of the RPF you know very well that in the aftermath of the Rwandan genocide the virtuous image projected by the FPR is now being seriously dented:
there is a growing body of evidence pointing to its involvement in war crimes and crimes against humanity in eastern Congo, for its alleged participation in the military operation that brought down Habyarimana’s plane, and more generally for its responsibility in the 1994 genocide.

For instance, in a provocatively titled article published in 2004 – “Provoking genocide: A revised history of the Rwanda Patriotic Front” – Dr Alan Kuperman squarely blamed the FPR for creating the conditions that led to genocide: “with the support of the international community”, he writes, “the FPR threatened Rwanda’s Hutu regime to such an extent that it retaliated with genocide”.

Based on open-ended interviews with several top-ranking civil servants and FPR officers, the author’s thesis is straightforward: “The Tutsi rebels expected their challenge to provoke genocidal retaliation but viewed this as an acceptable cost of achieving their goal of attaining power in Rwanda”.

Dr Alan Kuperman fully endorses Des Forges’s contention that all five major outbursts of anti-Tutsi violence from 1990 to 1993 were launched “in reaction to challenges that threatened Habyarimana’s control”.

He goes on to identify the “retaliatory massacres” triggered by FPR challenges.

The pattern of challenge and response that are analyzed by Kuperman points to a key aspect of the dynamics of violence preceding the genocide.

Do not forget to teach your daughter about such an untold truth about the Rwandan tragedy. This is one of your many duties should you not want your daughter or her children to keep fleeing for their safety or in order to get the education they deserve.

 
At February 8, 2009 at 3:25 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear Mamadou:

Let me be clear,my wisdom and humanity are perfectly intact. My praising of a man I consider a hero in our history, is not a demonstration of anger. Far from it. I will add that it is sad to see how quick and easily you take the words of Mr Kuperman, and Allison Des Forges as the gospel truth to fit whatever bias you might have towards the leadership in Rwanda today. To let you in on a little fact, soon after the 1994 genocide of Tutsis (yes, it actually happened) I met Ms Des Forges as she was trying to put together a document for Human Rights Watch focusing on the genocide...She was so excited and supportive of the then rebels who had just stopped the massacre with no assistance from the UN. However, when Mr Kagame turned out to be an independent thinker and leader who was not interested in doing business as usual - NGO mentality that needs wars,famine and tragic stories from Africa as a means to justify their fundraising and recognition in Washington DC, ms Des Forges's goodwill turned into acrimonious retaliation. I have been on the ground, beyond both borders working and treating the sick and feeding the hungry, Hutu or Tutsi or Twa! My friend, I dont need to quote a foreign historian writing from his or her cushy office about a subject they think they know or understand just because they are considered an "expert on the Rwanda Genocide" - Also, I'm quite concretly confident in what I need to teach my daughter. Thanks but no thanks for your advise on that matter - her education will never be compromised so much so that her college degrees,MBAs'or Phd's engulf all sense of common sense or the ability to ask why?
Sincerely,
Jackie

 
At February 8, 2009 at 4:33 PM , Blogger Mamadou Kouyate said...

Dear Jackie,

Do not let anyone fool you about the Rwandan genocide.It is real, it really hapenned and I completely agree with you.

However,it is also well known (and you seem to ignore it) that anyone who expresses anything different from the Rwandan Government's official version of the events that occured in Rwanda and in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC)is accused of being a Genocidaire.

Dr. Alison Des Forges happens to fall into that category in the eyes of the current Rwandan government as do some other Americans who happen to know more than what the Rwandan government would like them to know about these atrocities.

Dr Des Forges was once praised by the RPF for her famous book: Leave none to tell the story....but now she is banned from Rwanda and is accused of being interahamwe, genocidaire, etc.

For your info, here is an exerpt of the book: Leave none to tell the story.

RPF Challenges to Hutu Regime Provoke Retaliatory Massacres:

Date of Challenge-Type of Challenge- Months til retaliation –Date of retaliatory massacre-Location (geographic region).

Oct-90 -Invasion Oct-90-0-Mutara (NE) and Kibilira (North West)

Jan-91 -Attack on Ruhengeri -0- Jan/Feb-91 Ruhengeri (North West)

Jan-92 -Demands for power-sharing -2- Mar-92 Kibilira (North West) and Bugesera (South)

Aug-92 -First Arusha Protocol -0-Aug-92 Kibuye (West)

Jan-93 -Later Arusha Protocol -Jan-93 -0-Gisenyi (North West), Kibilira (North West) and Kibuye (West)

Sources:
Des Forges, Alison, et al. (1999). Leave None to Tell the Story: Genocide in Rwanda. Washington: Human Rights Watch. pp. 87-88

 
At February 8, 2009 at 10:37 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear Mamadou:

I have to believe that you cannot possibly be that naive or so ill-informed as to portray the 1990 - 1993 as the beginning and end of Rwanda's problems? I have no problem whatsoever calling a spade a spade, or pointing out dates, details and locations - However, lets be balanced in our search for truth, peace and justice - Why is it that almost every article I read or stumble upon on Rwanda's history only begins in 1990 - especially if the author is French, French Canadian or Francophone-related in any shape or form?? Why is it that you did not detail the accounts from 1963? and 67?, 73? - when I lost my father's brother who simply forgot to walk around that day with his ID card that identified whether he was Tutsi, Hutu, or Twa? - Why is it that there is selective amnesia about on these facts? War, as we have learnt from Iraq/USA war, is never a fair playing field - because innocent people die - hence the importance and need to respond to dire situations such as the 30-some years 2 million Rwandans appealed, demonstrated, held meetings and confronted the government at the time to recognize them as citizens of Rwanda - all in vain. Infact, I will quote Habyarimana.."Rwanda is a very small country and most of these refugees have been away for so long - why dont they apply for citizenship in the respective nations they are livin in ?" - Can you imagine hearing such a response while living in a refugee camp somewhere along the borders of your own country? And RPF "provoked" this genocide? Are you kidding me? Another thing, I hardly think anyone in their right minds would brand Dr Allison Des Forges an interahamwe or genocidaire - no matter which side of the fence she decides to sit on from day to day depending on which one suits her organization/NGO's stance that day or week or month...
Sincerely,
Jackie

 
At February 9, 2009 at 8:56 AM , Blogger Mamadou Kouyate said...

Dear Jackie,

I do not have documentation on the IN.YE.NZI war which I think may encompass some details of the accounts from 1963, 1967 and even 1973.

However, the following article may give you some insights into these dark moments:

The Acronym IN.YE.NZI: A Symbol of Bravery
(http://backtomyroots.wordpress.com/2008/12/13/the-acronym-inyenzi-a-symbol-of-bravery/)

If you do have more articles or books about this civil war please feel free to share them.

Our goal here is to raise awarness about so many crimes committed in Rwanda and in DRC, crimes that went uninvestigated and most of the culprits unprosecuted.

Together,
let's work towards an end of this culture of impunity widspread in the Great Lakes Region of Africa.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home